Buy Now, Pay Later: 3 regimes UK, EU and US rules for pay later

Buy Now, Pay Later in 2026: Business Models, Risks and Regulation

Rate this post

Explainer

  • Topic: How buy now, pay later (BNPL) works and how it is regulated
  • UK: The FCA has regulated third-party BNPL (“deferred payment credit”) since July 15, 2026
  • EU: The revised Consumer Credit Directive (CCD2) applies from November 20, 2026 and brings most BNPL into scope
  • US: The CFPB’s 2024 interpretive rule was withdrawn in 2025, and states such as New York and Illinois are writing their own rules
  • Takeaway: BNPL is moving from a lightly regulated checkout feature to regulated consumer credit

Buy now, pay later lets shoppers split a purchase into a few instalments, often with no interest if they pay on time. For merchants it can lift sales at checkout. For regulators it looks increasingly like consumer credit. This explainer covers how BNPL works, where the risks sit and how rules in the UK, EU and US now differ.

What BNPL is

The definitions vary by country. In the UK, the FCA describes the products it now regulates as “deferred payment credit”: interest-free credit repayable in 12 or fewer instalments over 12 months or less. The classic example is “pay in four”, with equal payments over several weeks.

How providers make money

  • Merchant fees. The retailer typically pays the provider a fee on each transaction in exchange for higher conversion or larger baskets.
  • Late fees and other charges. Some providers charge consumers when they miss a payment.
  • Interest on longer or larger plans. Some products offer longer terms with interest, which are regulated differently from short interest-free plans.

The economics depend on keeping losses low, so providers rely on fast, automated credit decisions at checkout.

Where the risks sit

  • Affordability. The FCA has pointed to people who use BNPL repeatedly and may not be able to afford it, as it said when confirming its rules.
  • Stacking. A shopper can hold plans with several providers at once, and a single provider may not see the others.
  • Disputes and refunds. Rights can depend on how the product is classed. The National Consumer Law Center has noted that consumer protections in the US are uncertain after the CFPB’s withdrawal of its interpretation.
  • Merchant risk. Merchants rely on a provider’s uptime, fees and treatment of their customers.

How the rules compare

Region Where it stands
United Kingdom From July 15, 2026, third-party BNPL is regulated by the FCA under its final rules (PS26/1, published February 11, 2026). Lenders need FCA authorisation or temporary permission, must follow the Consumer Duty, give clear upfront information, and customers gain access to the Financial Ombudsman Service. Agreements entered into before July 15 stay unregulated, and credit provided by the same business that sells the goods is not covered
European Union The revised Consumer Credit Directive (Directive (EU) 2023/2225) applies from November 20, 2026. According to a country-by-country summary, it brings most BNPL, small-value and interest-free credit into scope, requires creditworthiness assessments before agreements and gives consumers a right to human review of automated decisions. One legal summary notes that providers already active may have a transition period to November 2027 in some member states
United States (federal) The CFPB’s 2024 interpretive rule, which treated pay-in-four as card-like credit, was withdrawn in 2025, and the Bureau said it did not intend to reissue it, according to Consumer Finance Monitor
United States (states) New York’s BNPL Act was signed on May 9, 2025, and the state financial regulator published a proposed regulation on February 23, 2026 to create licensing and supervision. Illinois signed its Buy-Now-Pay-Later Loan Consumer Protection Act on June 25, 2026

What providers and merchants should do

  1. Map each product to a regime: interest-free short credit, longer interest-bearing credit and merchant-provided credit are treated differently.
  2. Document affordability and creditworthiness checks, because EU and UK rules both push toward evidence.
  3. Explain the terms in plain language before the customer commits, including what happens if a payment is missed.
  4. Plan for complaints and refunds, including access to ombudsman schemes where they apply.
  5. Check licences before you integrate. Merchants should confirm that their provider is authorised in each market.
  6. Watch state rules in the US, where licensing is arriving state by state.

A worked example (illustrative)

The numbers below are invented to show the mechanics. Real fees and loss rates vary by provider, market and merchant.

  • A shopper buys a $200 item and chooses to pay in four instalments of $50.
  • The merchant agrees to pay the BNPL provider a 5% fee on the sale: $10. The merchant receives $190 and the provider pays it out quickly.
  • If the shopper pays all four instalments on time, the provider has earned $10 on the sale, before its own costs of funding, fraud, support and technology.
  • If 3 purchases in every 100 were never repaid, the provider would lose $600 against $1,000 of merchant fees on those 100 sales. That is before funding and operating costs.

The sensitivity is the point: a small change in the share of unpaid instalments can wipe out the fee income. That is why providers invest heavily in fast credit decisions, and why regulators ask how those decisions are made.

Key dates at a glance

DateEvent
May 2024The CFPB issues an interpretive rule treating pay-in-four as card-like credit under US law
2025The CFPB withdraws that rule and later says it does not intend to reissue it
May 9, 2025New York’s BNPL Act is signed
February 11, 2026The FCA publishes its final BNPL rules (PS26/1)
February 23, 2026New York’s financial regulator publishes a proposed regulation for licensing and supervision
June 25, 2026Illinois signs its Buy-Now-Pay-Later Loan Consumer Protection Act
July 15, 2026UK regulation of third-party BNPL begins
November 20, 2026The EU’s revised Consumer Credit Directive (CCD2) applies

What shoppers should know

  • Check the due dates and set reminders, because a missed instalment can bring fees or affect future access.
  • Avoid stacking several plans at once. Each provider sees only its own plan.
  • Understand refunds. Find out how returns are handled and when the next instalment stops.
  • Know your protections. In the UK, regulated BNPL now gives access to the Financial Ombudsman Service. Elsewhere, rights depend on local rules and the provider.
  • Treat it as credit. It is borrowing, even when it feels like a payment option.

What merchants should check before adding BNPL

  • Authorisation. Is the provider licensed or registered where your customers live?
  • Total cost. Beyond the headline fee, ask about settlement timing, chargeback and refund handling, and any minimum volumes.
  • Customer experience. The provider’s checkout and support reflect on your brand.
  • Data and privacy. Understand what customer data is shared and how it is used.
  • Exit terms. Can you switch providers without disrupting orders in progress?

Common mistakes

  • Treating all BNPL as one product when the rules differ by term length, interest and who the lender is.
  • Assuming merchant-provided credit and third-party credit are regulated the same way. In the UK they are not.
  • Launching in a new country without checking transition dates and registration requirements.
  • Measuring only conversion uplift and ignoring refunds, disputes and complaints.

Frequently asked questions

Is buy now, pay later a loan?

In practice, yes. The UK now regulates third-party BNPL as consumer credit, and the EU’s revised directive treats most BNPL as consumer credit from November 2026.

Do the new UK rules apply to older agreements?

No. According to the FCA, agreements taken out before July 15, 2026 remain unregulated, and credit provided by the same business that sells the goods is not covered.

Does the EU have a transition period?

Some member states give providers that were already active a transition period, according to one legal summary, but a new provider generally needs to meet the rules from November 20, 2026. Check your national law.

Why is US regulation unsettled?

The federal interpretation was withdrawn, so states are writing their own rules. New York and Illinois are examples, and others may follow.

The Funding Journal view

The direction of travel is clear in the UK and EU: BNPL is treated as credit, with affordability checks, clear information and a route to redress. In the US the rules are less settled, which means providers face a patchwork rather than a single standard. For merchants, the practical risk is not the product but the partner: a provider that cannot show its authorisation and complaints process in a market is a risk to your brand there.

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice. See our disclaimer. Facts last checked October 26, 2026; rules and company details change, so confirm current terms before you act.

Published by The Funding Journal Editorial. Practical, sourced writing on fintech, crowdfunding, investment platforms, SaaS and AI, and the stories of founders who raised capital.

Similar Posts