Secondary markets for private shares: 1 year the Reg CF resale lock-up

How Secondary Markets for Private Shares Work

Rate this post

Explainer

  • Topic: How investors sell shares in private companies
  • US rule: Securities bought under Regulation Crowdfunding generally cannot be resold for one year
  • Exceptions: Transfers back to the issuer, to an accredited investor, in a registered offering, or to certain family members in specific cases
  • Takeaway: Even after the lock-up, a buyer may not exist, so liquidity is never guaranteed

Buying shares in a private company is simple compared with selling them. There is no exchange, the shares usually come with transfer restrictions, and finding a buyer at a fair price can take years. Secondary markets exist to make that second step easier. This explainer covers why private shares are hard to sell, what the US crowdfunding rules say, and what a platform needs to build to support resale.

Why private shares are hard to sell

  • No public listing. There is no continuous market, so no ready buyer and no daily price.
  • Transfer restrictions in the company’s documents. Common terms include a right of first refusal for the company or existing investors, and board consent for transfers.
  • Securities-law holding periods. Many private offerings come with legal restrictions on how soon shares can be resold.
  • Few buyers and little information. Buyers want recent financials and a credible valuation, which small companies rarely publish often.
  • Paperwork and records. Every transfer must update the share register and meet identity checks on both sides.

The one-year rule for Regulation Crowdfunding

In the United States, the SEC states that securities purchased in a crowdfunding transaction generally cannot be resold for one year. The rule itself, 17 CFR 227.501, bars transfer by any purchaser during the one-year period beginning when the securities were issued, with limited exceptions: transfers back to the issuer, to an accredited investor, as part of a registered offering, and to certain family members in connection with events such as death or divorce.

Two details are easy to miss. First, as Davis Polk noted, the restriction applies to any purchaser during that year, not only the original buyer. Second, the end of the year does not create a market. Republic’s investor guide makes the same point: after twelve months federal law allows a sale, but state or foreign laws may still apply, and there is no guarantee that a buyer will appear.

How investors actually sell

  1. Company buyback or tender offer. The company, or an investor group it organises, offers to buy shares at a set price on set dates.
  2. Private sale to an eligible buyer. For example, a sale to an accredited investor, subject to the company’s transfer rules.
  3. Matched trades on a secondary platform. A venue lists sell and buy interest and settles transfers. Such venues generally operate under the local rules for trading platforms, which in the US means regulated broker-dealer or alternative-trading-system structures.
  4. A registered offering or listing. An IPO or similar event lets holders sell more freely.

Regulators are also carving narrow routes. In Australia, for example, ASIC remade its low-volume financial market exemption in October 2026 so that the transaction-value ceiling rose from AUD 1.5 million to AUD 2.5 million in any 12-month period, with the 100-transaction cap kept, according to GECA’s October round-up. GECA describes it as a narrow secondary-market route, not a change to the crowdfunding raise cap.

What a platform needs to support resale

  • Lock-up tracking for each investor and each security, so early transfers are blocked.
  • Eligibility and identity checks on both the seller and the buyer at the time of resale.
  • Order handling: a bulletin board, matching or scheduled windows, with clear pricing rules.
  • A reliable share register or transfer-agent link so ownership updates are legally effective.
  • Ongoing company disclosures so buyers can price what they are buying.
  • Fee, tax-reporting and settlement flows, plus the licences your regulator requires for running a venue.

If the share register moves onto a blockchain, some of this gets easier and some does not. We explain how tokenization changes resale in our guide to tokenized real estate and private equity.

Risks and realities for investors

  • You may never find a buyer, or only at a price below what you paid.
  • Prices on thin markets can be volatile and hard to verify.
  • Early-stage companies fail often, and shares can end up worthless.
  • Fees and delays can reduce what you receive.

What founders and operators can do

  • Tell investors plainly at the outset that liquidity is limited and not guaranteed.
  • Consider a clear buyback or tender policy once the company is profitable or well funded.
  • Keep investor reporting regular, because informed buyers pay better prices.
  • If you run a platform, plan transfer and register tooling early; it is far harder to add after thousands of investors have joined.

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice. See our disclaimer. Facts last checked October 23, 2026; rules and prices change, so confirm current terms before you act.

Published by The Funding Journal Editorial. Practical, sourced writing on fintech, crowdfunding, investment platforms, SaaS and AI, and the stories of founders who raised capital.

Similar Posts